You locked your eyes on me
Stared into my lost soul
You said that you'd love me
And you'd make my heart feel whole
But then you said you had another
It tore my world when I discovered
Emotions broke to know you had a long time lover

Oh no, I'm not your second choice
I should come first
Oh no, I'm not your second choice
I'm not your second choice

I cried out all my pain
Worked through all of my tears
I'm now out of the rain
My comeback is in full gear
When you said that you had a lover
It tore my world but I recovered
You had your chance for true romance
Now I'll save it for another

Oh no, I'm not your second choice
I should come first
Oh no, I'm not your second choice
I'm not your second choice
Oh no, I'm not your second choice
I should come first
Oh no, I'm not your second choice
I'm not your second choice

Don't look my way, don't say you'll stay
Don't promise me that you'll change your ways
Don't look my way, don't say you'll stay
I know that you won't change your ways

Oh no, I'm not your second choice
I should come first
Oh no, I'm not your second choice
I'm not your second choice
Oh no, I'm not your second choice
I should come first
Oh no, I'm not your second choice
I'm not your second choice